A collaboration with The New School & the European Democracy Institute
 
The Return of Authority: Young Men and the Search for Strong Leadership

The Return of Authority: Young Men and the Search for Strong Leadership

Written by:
Photo: President Donald Trump with participants in American Legion Boys Nation, July 26, 2017. Official White House photo by Joyce Boghosian. Public domain.
Photo: President Donald Trump with participants in American Legion Boys Nation, July 26, 2017. Official White House photo by Joyce Boghosian. Public domain.

Why do some young men look to confrontational leaders for the security they once expected from public institutions? Their support is often discussed in terms of ideology, resentment, or backlash. Another possibility deserves attention: when institutions seem unable to offer a credible path to adulthood, leaders who project certainty can become substitutes for the authority those institutions have lost.

Economic insecurity and changing social expectations may create a demand for direction and protection that established parties struggle to answer. A Jungian reading offers one way to interpret the symbolic appeal of strong leadership.

Analyses of the 2024 US election by the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers University and CIRCLE at Tufts University identify differences between the voting patterns of young men and young women. In “Argentina’s New Conservative Coalition,” Ernesto Calvo and colleagues show how young male voters formed an important part of Javier Milei’s support. European research, including Đorđe Milosav et al.’s “The Youth Gender Gap in Support for the Far Right,” examines a similar gap. These findings concern different electorates and political movements; they do not establish a single Western trend or a shared psychological cause.

They do, however, invite a question about representation. What do these leaders offer voters who feel poorly served by existing institutions? Trump and Milei differ in their economic programmes and national contexts, but both make confrontation with established elites central to their public identities. Their appeal may involve the promise that someone will finally take responsibility for breaking an intolerable stalemate.

The economic background matters. As John Weinberg recounts in “The Great Recession and Its Aftermath,” the 2008 financial crisis destroyed jobs, damaged household wealth, and exposed the fragility of the promise that education and hard work would deliver security. The rescue of financial institutions also invited a bitter comparison: institutions could receive extraordinary protection while individuals absorbed unemployment, debt, and the loss of their homes. Financial recovery did not automatically repair that breach of confidence.

For younger adults facing insecure work or expensive housing, the consequences extend beyond income. Financial independence, a home, and the possibility of forming a family become harder to envisage. These difficulties affect women as well as men. For men who still measure themselves against expectations of being providers, however, the distance between those expectations and their material prospects may carry a particular burden.

Cultural change adds another layer. Expanding rights and challenging inherited hierarchies have opened valuable freedoms. Yet the weakening of older masculine roles does not ensure that everyone finds a convincing alternative. Some young men may experience the transition as uncertainty about where they belong and what society expects of them. That possibility should be explored without treating equality itself as the source of their difficulties.

Economic frustration alone cannot explain why a voter chooses one political response over another. Nor can uncertainty about masculinity explain the diversity of young men’s political commitments. The argument here concerns how these pressures might interact: material insecurity can make questions of recognition and belonging more urgent, while a leader’s certainty can turn a political programme into a promise of personal reassurance.

Jung’s account of archetypes, developed in The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious and Symbols of Transformation, provides a vocabulary for interpreting that promise. In a Jungian reading, the father figure can symbolize structure, protection, direction, and limits. This is a symbolic role, not a claim that political authority must be male or that patriarchal arrangements should be restored. A woman leader can project such authority, just as a man can fail to do so.

Applied to politics, this perspective suggests that a forceful leader may be invested with expectations that exceed any specific policy. Supporters may see someone who can restore coherence to a world they experience as unstable. Confrontation itself can then become reassuring: it appears to demonstrate that the leader recognizes the disorder and has the will to act against it.

This interpretation has limits. Electoral gender gaps do not demonstrate the operation of a paternal archetype. Establishing such a connection would require evidence about voters’ motivations and comparisons with competing explanations, including partisan identity, policy preferences, and media use. Jung’s contribution here is an interpretive lens for the emotional meaning of authority, rather than an explanation established by the election results.

The distinction also matters politically. A demand for effective leadership is compatible with democracy; transferring unlimited trust to a leader can weaken the institutions that make power accountable. The same promise of protection can therefore lead in different directions. Whether it produces competent government or personal dependence depends on how authority is exercised and constrained.

For democratic parties, the practical response cannot stop at condemning voters’ attraction to strength. They need to make institutional authority credible through affordable routes to independence, reliable public services, and decisions whose purposes people can understand. Recognition matters too: young men should be able to discuss insecurity and uncertainty without being treated as a problem merely for expressing them.

This does not require reviving discredited hierarchies or surrendering gains in equality. It requires showing that democratic institutions can provide direction and protection while remaining open to challenge. A society that offers freedom but leaves people unable to imagine a viable future creates an opening for leaders who promise certainty on personal terms.

The question raised by strong leaders is therefore also a question about the institutions around them. Why do some citizens no longer expect those institutions to offer security, direction, and a place in the future? Until democratic politics answers that question in people’s lives, the promise embodied by a commanding personality will retain its force. 

Author

  • Luis Juanicó

    Luis Juanicó is an Argentine researcher at CONICET whose scientific work focuses on energy systems and technological change. He also writes essays on literature, culture, and public affairs.